So, I had to buy a new set of Tarot cards for the Fortune’s Fool RPG, which uses pulls from a Tarot deck instead of dice rolls. I actually already own a couple of decks; they were given to me by friends, but most of them have nonstandard/ridiculous iconography. (I just can’t see using the Hello Kitty Color Me Tarot to decide the life or the death of someone’s PC.) After some waffling, I chose Lo Scarabo’s Pictorial Key Tarot.
Pros:
I chose this deck primarily because it includes traditional iconography and it’s easy to discern suit and number when you pull a card. Suit/number determine successes and fails in Fortune’s Fool (as well as spellcasting mana and degree of success,) so it’s imperative that players be able to identify both easily. I’m fairly happy with the deck overall. The cards have handsome backs, they come with a handy carrying pouch, and they’re not so thick and unwieldy that they’re impossible to shuffle. Buuuut…
Cons:
The computer generated images on these cards look like the Sims.
Consider the Temperance card:

Now consider it like this:

Yep. Somehow, the card makes more sense, doesn’t it?
Here’s Strength with Simlish bubbles that I assume approximate what’s happening:
Now let’s talk the card in this set that gets my vote for both favorite and least favorite, the Moon. The Moon card represents the life of the imagination and the subconscious, but not necessarily in a positive way; the person who gets this card use may fantasy to escape real life instead of releasing his imagination in artistic endeavors. The Pictorial Key cards has a nicely rendered domesticated dog/wild wolf image, which I think nicely suggests the divide between conscious (domesticated) and unconscious (wild) self. Here’s the part of the Moon card that I really like:
That’s a thoughtful, easily interpretable image, really. But then, the artist had to go and include this:

NO, U!
WTF?! Why the hell is Cthulhu in this picture?
Anyway, overall, I’m pretty happy with this deck for the purposes of playing FF, but I think that–what’s that? What, Mr. Cthulhu?
Oh.

Screw it. I’m going back to bed.



3 comments
Comments feed for this article
August 21, 2011 at 10:07 am
Jay
Hey, Jay Stratton here – author of Fortune’s Fool. That Moon plus Cthulhu picture is hilarious. Laughed out loud when you showed it!
Thanks for taking the time to try and blog on Fortune’s Fool!
The process of creating the game has resulted in me having dozens of Tarot decks – some of which are easy to use and beautiful – others suck. But adding cthulhu to the moon card is about the worst I’ve seen!
August 21, 2011 at 11:38 am
llanwyre
Wow! Thanks so much for stopping by! Needless to say, I am a huge fan of your work; I think FF is one of the most innovative AND playable new games out there right now. (All too often, games are one or the other–either innovative OR playable.) Glad you enjoyed the post. The saving grace to the Pictorial Key deck is its engaging minor arcana, which are usually so ho-hum, but the major arcana are all either incredibly bizarre or hilariously banal. (The Empress looks like an unhappy soccer mom forced to dress up for the Ren Faire.) If you have a favorite deck or few decks, I’m all ears…
August 23, 2011 at 8:57 am
Jay
Thanks for your kind words about Fortune’s Fool! We are very proud of it – and Grimm Tales, the supplement we just put out.
I see what you are saying about this particular deck! Pretty funny.
Couple decks we have enjoyed are The Golden Tarot by Kat Black – very good art, very thematic and easy to read.
http://goldentarot.com/
Also the Deviant Moon Tarot http://www.deviantmoon.com/wordpress/
Very fun deck, though a little harder to read.